You've been reforging accessories wrong.

My terraria Character by acejt on DeviantArt

Menacing treasure bag” +4% damage : r/Terraria

Terraria Eye of Cthulhu Large Wall Decal

Lucky is NOT better than Menacing (Terraria)

Hey guys! I need help Terraria Community Forums

Yes, I play terraria

Modifiers - Terraria Wiki

Aquatic Menace 3! Roll20 Marketplace: Digital goods for online tabletop gaming

Steam Community :: Guide :: A Guide to Journey's End PvP

advice for FTW WOF? All weapons are reforged to the best, most accessories are Menacing/Warding. I've got more potions they're just not in my inventory. : r/Terraria